lol, yep I mean the Metallica version...actually one of my favourite albums of all time!

I only need two songs:

Walk on the Water - Creedence Clearwater Revival
Jesus is just Alright - The Byrds

and follow the good example

I thought "Jesus is just alright" was by the Doobie brothers?  Anyways, can I trade in my songs for a friend on the island......preferably a tall dark and handsome one?

spoon

You can trade your songs for me.

That's it.

Ok?

true story .....recently  saw an interview with a guy who was shipwrecked on an island for 18 months and they asked him what would he recommend ....uknow....radio. swissarmy knife,fishing kit etc.......
his answer
a brunette.

Nah, the Byrds version is much better, and part of the soundtrack to the cult movie Easy Rider from 1969.

Nothing to do with the music I'd take on a desert island but.....

These two guys and a girl were stranded on a desert island - there was food and water, but nothing else to do except enjoy each others' company 
After a year, the girl got sick and died.
The two guys were devastated, naturally, that they had lost their female company - but needing some comfort they did what was not necessarily natural to them but still relieved their frustrations.
This situation continued for another couple of months until one of them turned to the other and said  "I feel terrible about what we're doing.  I really think we should stop".
The other guy said "Yes, I know that you're right.  I supposed we should start to dig a hole so we can bury her"!!!
 

I'll have to think about what music I'd take though

Jim - all I have to say to that is EEWWWWWWW!!!!!