I liked it, it was good i want some more

I love your lyrics - really nice style.  Recording quality is pretty good too.  Only criticism would be of a the fairly generic chord progression, but you do mix it up with different strumming patterns which is good.  I was about ot suggest maybe adding some other parts to it, but on second thought I think that a major strength and contributing factor to the feel of this song is its simplicity.  So - keep it as it is!

Kobeshi

No drums required. its good song which I'm sure the ladies would enjoy you playing it to them live. lol. Keep it up.

An excellent composition and recording.  The lyrics really speak to me.  Like it that the imaginary roses may be discarded, says that something lives even if not in the real world.  Yes, a good hook.  Your guitar is very clean and is perfect accompaniment.  Like others have mentioned, additional instruments should be minimal as the tune stands very well on its own.  Great job -- I voted.