well, at this time i listened to this song for more then 10 times i guess, that slide guitar keeps finding my ears everytime you touch a string, and it never bores ! ! !
again a great played and produced piece my friend!
this slide guitar in the beginning promises me much ..., so soulfull played!
but to me the accompany and most important; the vox, as perfect as they are made, it lacks some soul , guts and liveness as in your guitar part, the hihat really bothers me from the start till the end :-)
i know your a pro and will not be hurt by these words, its just an honest opinion, and much i compared to your first song which impressed me a lot and showed me more of your vocal capacities., imo some more power in vox and drums and its 100% ace
also i think this song is made with tons of knowledge and lots of dedication!
i can see this song as an easy going tune spiced up with a wild guitar, or i hear a wild rockin guitar player with an easy band
i prefer the first one
for all i know:
Max
btw. did i mention i lóve that slide guitar?
again a great played and produced piece my friend!
this slide guitar in the beginning promises me much ..., so soulfull played!
but to me the accompany and most important; the vox, as perfect as they are made, it lacks some soul , guts and liveness as in your guitar part, the hihat really bothers me from the start till the end :-)
i know your a pro and will not be hurt by these words, its just an honest opinion, and much i compared to your first song which impressed me a lot and showed me more of your vocal capacities., imo some more power in vox and drums and its 100% ace
also i think this song is made with tons of knowledge and lots of dedication!
i can see this song as an easy going tune spiced up with a wild guitar, or i hear a wild rockin guitar player with an easy band
i prefer the first one
for all i know:
Max
btw. did i mention i lóve that slide guitar?
wow! thanks Max and Swordfish! Max, you gave me some stuff to think about ( things I hadn't considered previously) Your feedback is important to me and I'm certain that it will help me improve. Now that I listen to it again, I see what you mean (about the accompaniment and the singing lacking soul...I agree...they do sound a bit pedestrian. The problems with the hi-hat were readily apparent to me....it's even a bit annoying). I'm a novice vocalist (I've ALWAYS wanted to sing with some soul...but that part just hasn't come yet. Maybe I should take up cigarette smoking and resume drinking hard liquor.....to get that "gravel" in my voice...joking of course). I probably shouldn't admit this, but I actually recorded this song in a few different keys. I had somewhat of a dilemma.....when I played in a key that was better for my voice to project more, the slide guitar was forced into a range that wasn't good....so I decided to support the guitar, because my singing wasn't THAT great even at it's best! Anyway ,this gives me something to work on. Swordfish, I appreciate your feedback on the clarity of the voice. I was a little concerned that the voice may be too "out front". I'm glad to hear that is workable. Thanks again to the both of you.
my shoes are tied |
hmm this has been on the amp since April , I am going to have to start going to everyones home page and just going down the list.... What a great song... I am more with fish on this I like your vox like it is... I think getting to rocky with it would be outta character with the music... this is just what it is supposed to be.. the mix is fine for me cause I can hear the vox and the slide guitar perfectly and they are the stars of this show! the rest is just backing blues filler ..very well done filler but still the vox and lead guitar shines on this song...
getting downloaded into playlist on computer and onto cd for the car...
top vote from me too
greg
getting downloaded into playlist on computer and onto cd for the car...
top vote from me too
greg
I know you have the soul and capabilities Battlecat, i just think they didnt come out as well as they could ,probably caused by recording it over and over.
others seem to like the contrast in the song, so, its just my opinion, and i tried to make clear why i liked your other song better, because i hear that soul there.
just my honest thoughts, didnt want to to say 'all great' out of politeness
greetz
others seem to like the contrast in the song, so, its just my opinion, and i tried to make clear why i liked your other song better, because i hear that soul there.
just my honest thoughts, didnt want to to say 'all great' out of politeness
greetz
MaxdB wrote…
I know you have the soul and capabilities Battlecat, i just think they didnt come out as well as they could ,probably caused by recording it over and over.
others seem to like the contrast in the song, so, its just my opinion, and i tried to make clear why i liked your other song better, because i hear that soul there.
just my honest thoughts, didnt want to to say 'all great' out of politeness
greetz
Completely understood, Max! I see both sides of it. Again, I value your observation and, in the long run, I want to implant as much "soul" into my work as I can (this is an important value for me, as I grew up with a passion for that. Even though I can see places where I need to improve along those lines, your observation serves to confirm mine. In other words, you're speaking my language....so make no mistake about it, I appreciate your honest and knowledgeable feedback!)
Wow, this is an incredibly tight composition! All the good things I could say have been said - so I'll just say 'ditto everyone else's compliments' haha. As far as fixing things go, the only element I would look at is the hi-hat as puppetxeno I believe mentioned. Just occasionaly adding an open hit on it or maybe a triplet/something along those lines. Just have a play around, but of course not too much.
Great song!!!
Great song!!!
Batulkat!!!
You never tells me yous gots the song up.
You make me sad
BUT then I got happy, because I love the hell out of this song!
You're prally unaware. But there is a guy named Tai Mi Shu (or something) who does funny chinese rap. Well, he does it in english, but with a chinese accent. And your refrain is walkign is easier once I tie my shoe" makes me laugh cuz I think of the song.
But then again, back to THIS song. Really southern... the second southern thing I've listen to in a row. The effects on the guitar really let it stand out while not being a real distraction. The piano, at times, annoyed me a little but ont he whole it kicked ass.
Like my grandpa always says, "You gots you a voice and yous gots to sing from the heart, and if that aint workin, singin' from the mouth works pretty damn good, too.!"
You never tells me yous gots the song up.
You make me sad
BUT then I got happy, because I love the hell out of this song!
You're prally unaware. But there is a guy named Tai Mi Shu (or something) who does funny chinese rap. Well, he does it in english, but with a chinese accent. And your refrain is walkign is easier once I tie my shoe" makes me laugh cuz I think of the song.
But then again, back to THIS song. Really southern... the second southern thing I've listen to in a row. The effects on the guitar really let it stand out while not being a real distraction. The piano, at times, annoyed me a little but ont he whole it kicked ass.
Like my grandpa always says, "You gots you a voice and yous gots to sing from the heart, and if that aint workin, singin' from the mouth works pretty damn good, too.!"
Sorry, you do not have access to post...
Wanna post? Join Today!