i started out recording on a 4 track doing our whole band . had to do the drums on one, bass on the other, guitar on the other, mix um the best i could, then bounce them to one trak.
start adding lead guitar and vocals to the other tracks get the best mix possible then I would dump that onto a two track cassette deck.

It's a real pain to record that way. your doing a good job of it though.

Your on the right track.
The song needs vocals with good lyrics is how i like to round it out.
A 4 track most of us got our start. not downing your recording it takes time
to learn to mix well.
Over all i like the song maybe less guitar solo.
sound more modern rock to me.
don't like to compare other bands, It sounds Like Chill!

Thats What my band does. I think your band just needs vocals. So, what I'd do is have your guitarist of bass player sing. It won't be the best, but hey, the pepole get what they want. Thats what my band does.

Overall, nice job. Keep it up!

What a really good song.
I'd let a lead singer take over from the solo guitarist though.
Someone to let you carry on funking that excellent rhythm you guys have got going on in there.