hmm let me know if i catch the idea fish:

are you propossing the vote sistem with smileys as this

so can we vote a song with JUST happy faces or what??

i mean

Fantastic (old 100%) 
Great (91-995)
Cool (81-90%)   
Could sound better (71-80%) 
hmmm (61-70%) 
What's the idea (51-60%) 

or less with
         

well, i hope you don't vote my comment as:
   or

lol

(withoutsplash) Dodo

what I think of the stars: 
what I think of your idea: 
what I think of THIS SITE:::       


...
 

Hey, come to think of it, http://remix.kwed.org/ has a smiley-based rating system. It's just a matter of UI though, underneath it's all just an average of collected data.

I like the stars. Would love to be able to see my average percentages again though... Really...

smileys might be interesting. though I'm fine with the system as is.

I'm with you on the average percentages pup.